ANZAC Day (interlude 6)

Today I got out of bed, bundled up Toop for her walk, and raised the Australian flag before heading off. I’m not particularly patriotic or caught up in symbolism or flag-waving, literal or otherwise. But I do like the odd gesture, particularly if it’s easy for me and mildly interesting. And the ANZACs deserve my respects.

High-minded talk about dying for my freedom and putting their lives and limbs on the line so that future generations may enjoy the liberties and luxuries we do aside, and cynical muttering about how wars and suffering don’t seem to have stopped even more aside, those old boys – indeed the old boys and girls of that entire era – were tough, and did a hideously difficult and painful thing for what they believed was a good cause. And I can’t and won’t argue with that.

If there’s one thing that living in a “foreign” country has taught me (and there are many things), it’s that there aren’t any bad guys. Heck, I’ve moved to a country that was on the other side during the war (did you know that Finland and Great Britain are the only two democracies to ever declare war on each other? I saw it on Qi once), but the Finns weren’t bad guys. They didn’t particularly like the Nazis, but it was them or the Russians. And ultimately the Finns had to take on Russia anyway.

And while I won’t go so far as to say the Nazis weren’t bad guys – their policies and actions were as disgusting and inhuman as any enacted by people in wartime – I think it’s safe to say that most of them, like the Russians and pretty much everyone else, were terrified, doing what they had been told was right for them and their families against an enemy they’d been lied to about relentlessly, following their orders[1] and doing what they thought was the right and noble thing. I like to believe that there was not a single person, barring the odd psychopath, who would not have preferred to just sit it out and get along.

[1] And okay, the “just following orders” chestnut is an old one, not a legitimate excuse for killing, let alone the greater atrocities. But it is a very human thing, and not a trait unique to the armed forces. I’m in a position not to judge, so I try not to. It’s easy to tell right from wrong when you’ve never been confronted by two or more hideously wrong choices, and had your death and the deaths of your family held up as an alternative.

Yes, it’s easy to be a judgemental hippy while I’m sitting in my peaceful home, with my fat belly full of breakfast and no particular fears – all due, to some degree or other, to the people who fought and bled in the past to make this world happen. I don’t want to sound sanctimonious. If anything, the fact that these people did such things that no sound-minded person would ever want to do is proof of their greatness.

But here in this graveyard it’s still No-Man’s Land,

The countless white crosses stand mute in the sand,

To man’s blind indifference to his fellow man,

To a whole generation that was butchered and damned.

People can be lied to. Mobs can be dangerous when whipped up. Leaders can be ambitious, stupid, insane, or simply intent on maintaining their power by keeping said mobs distracted and pointed at each other. Sometimes this turns into a perfect storm of good intentions, nationalism, ignorance and hate, and then wars happen. But actual evil?

I don’t know about that.

I think the only demons we bring into a war are the ones we create. Of our enemies, with lies and propaganda and ignorance-fuelled assumptions, and of ourselves, with the tiny half-step each new fear and each new hatred forces us to take. A half-step here where we repeat an unverified story someone tells us, a half-step there where we assume the worst of the enemy of the hour instead of trusting our own senses and looking for some sign of shared humanity. A half-step where we voluntarily hand over some precious element of our lives to a mindless government machine because the illusion of safety is more important – or just more convenient – than the responsibility and accountability that comes with true liberty. But what would I know?

Half-step, half-step, half-step.

Until one day we look back and we can’t see the line we’d drawn for ourselves, back when our world wasn’t burning and everything seemed so simple.

The ANZACs didn’t die for our freedom or legal system or privileges or lifestyle. They didn’t die for anything so small and petty. They died for us. And I’ve hoisted the flag and piped at enough memorials to feel embarrassed on behalf of anyone who says those guys would have wanted any sort of war to still be going on.

They fought and died so this sort of shit would never happen again. Nothing less.

Nothing.

It’s insulting to their memory to call them naïve. It’s not their fault we failed them.

This is what I mourn, in my own self-righteous and over-privileged way, on ANZAC Day.

This entry was posted in Hatboy's Nuggets of Crispy-Fried Wisdom and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to ANZAC Day (interlude 6)

  1. Very well said, thank you for educating me about ANZAC and its associated day! I feel a lot of the discussion here pertains to my views, which in many liberal ways are similar to your views. But, if this ANZAC Day is about WW I (one), as wikipedia tells me) I have a hard time criticizing peoples for their ignorance. Or maybe that should be persons…hmm. I mean general groups of citizens of various countries.

    Let’s face it, to say methods of curing ignorance back in the 1910s was scarce compared to today is to understate by several orders of magnitude. So, while I tend to hold the above-criticized views as they pertain to persons today who allow this ignorance to rule them, I have a harder time doing the same for those so far into the past. So, you’re good in my book, man ;D

    Given what my government and corporations have been up to for some time now, a great deal of what you said also hit home for me, and hard. You have to have faith, I guess, that one day the truth will out and no one can stay asleep forever (thinking of the ignorant Republicans who are suckered all the time by their politicians and talk show hosts).

    -Aaron

    • stchucky says:

      Not … quite sure what you’re getting at, the ignorance I criticise here is not really to do with ignorance of ANZAC itself. Outside Australia and New Zealand, even the Allies (I know, I’m mixing wars) wouldn’t be expected to know this stuff, let alone any others. That’s no big deal, and I agree with you that as we exceed a hundred years since the event, there’s a point at which people should let go of the past. Although there’s something to be said for remembering and learning rather than forgetting and repeating. Which we, as humanity, seem to be doing a lot of.

      The ignorance I was mostly talking about is the sort that’s perpetuating the wars and hatred going on in the world today. But I think I’ll sit on further ranting for now.

      • I…got all that buddy. I was just thinking of how/why I would or would not criticize persons in the 1910’s for ignorance in believing government propaganda. And I decided I would not. Basically we have far less excuses today for being ignorant than they did back in the day.

        I know you weren’t calling folks like me ignorant for not knowing about ANZAC. And, I wasn’t saying anyone should let go of that past. Not sure where that came from, we missed each other passing in opposite directions here! LOL

        It’s great to remember the sacrifice, AND the ignorance that led to it. IMO. And I think that’s what you were saying, too.

      • stchucky says:

        In that case, definitely. Agreed on all counts. Misunderstanding on my part, I was thrown by your first paragraph outlining your lack of familiarity with ANZAC Day and then segueing into your pass-giving for people’s ignorance, and I never regained my feet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s